Wine Insiders Reviews

Wine Insiders has an overall rating of 4.7 based on 27 reviews. Customer feedback on Wine Insiders is mixed: Wine Insiders reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide selection of wines, competitive pricing, convenient delivery options, and excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to wine enthusiasts looking for variety and convenience. However, Wine Insiders is often criticized for its limited information on wine origins, occasional shipping delays, higher prices for some premium wines, and mixed quality in wine selections.

4.7/5.0

27 reviews

5 Stars

20

4 Stars

4

3 Stars

2

2 Stars

0

1 Star

0

All Wine Insiders Reviews (27)
terence-Gideon
May 31, 2026
"Really easy to pause when I needed to"
I skipped a month without any trouble, and my settings updated right away. There was just something about it that felt simple and stress-free, which I really appreciated
lucy1989
May 26, 2026
"Smooth checkout and no funny business"
I’m always a little nervous with online orders because I don’t want to get fooled by some weird checkout trick or surprise fee at the end. But this was actually super easy. I picked out my bottles, the discount showed up right away, and I was paid up in just a few minutes. Shipping info was clear too, with no odd steps or glitches. it felt straightforward, which I really appreciated.
jack-Meacham
May 19, 2026
"Found my go-to bottles again"
I stopped in looking for my usual bottles and, sure enough, they had them like always. It’s become one of those places I can count on when I don’t feel like hunting around...
devinjohnson2189
May 15, 2026
"My wine order from Wine Insiders..."
My wine order from Wine Insiders arrived exactly the way I placed it. Every bottle matched my list, and there were no mix-ups or missing items.
I’ve had the wrong bottles show up from other sites before, so I trusted my instinct to double-check this one right away. Everything was correct, which was a nice change and definitely matters to me.
judy_Paulsen81
May 11, 2026
"Definitely ordering again"
I had a great experience and feel really good about this purchase. Everything went smoothly, and it’s the kind of quality that makes you confident about coming back. I’ll definitely be ordering again soon
RichardHeminger
May 09, 2026
"I signed up mostly to test it out..."
I signed up mostly to test it out, but I knew I didn’t want to risk getting charged for another order if I decided not to continue. When it came time to cancel, I was expecting some annoying runaround, but it was straightforward. I found the option quickly, didn’t have to argue with anyone, and got a confirmation after, which made me feel better. I’m always a little cautious with subscriptions, so I appreciated that canceling wasn’t a whole ordeal.
yvette.Townsend
May 04, 2026
"Cracked bottle, but they fixed it"
One of the bottles showed up cracked, so it leaked all over the box. I contacted support, and because they needed proof, I had to send a few photos. After that, I waited a couple days and they sent a replacement. It worked out in the end, but it was still a bit of a hassle.
kirby.Sanchez
April 29, 2026
"I honestly enjoyed the flavor"
I tried a few bottles, and to me they all tasted really good. I’d say the flavor is smooth and easy to drink, which made the whole experience enjoyable.
JohnEwing_61
April 27, 2026
"I’ll admit I mostly zeroed in on the..."
I’ll admit I mostly zeroed in on the promo price and didn’t pay a ton of attention to everything else at first. But for what I paid, it ended up being a solid deal. The wines were decent, and I didn’t have anything to complain about.
travis.Friedman
April 06, 2026
"Honestly Shocked It Showed Up Right on Time"
My order actually arrived exactly when they said it would, and I was weirdly thrilled about it. No delays, no drama, nothing missing, just a smooth delivery like some kind of small miracle.
Tonya-feldman
March 29, 2026
"Liked choosing my own wines, but I still had a few doubts"
I was a little skeptical at first because I hate getting stuck with a random box full of bottles I won’t drink. The best part about Wine Insiders was being able to swap things around and add more reds, since that’s what I actually like. The site was easy to use, though I still found myself second-guessing a few picks. Shipping went fine and nothing showed up damaged, which was a relief. Overall I’m happy with it, mostly because I didn’t feel forced into wines I didn’t want.
william_Peterson94
March 26, 2026
"Good wines for the price"
I’ve ordered from Wine Insiders a few times now the value has been solid. Most of the bottles were way cheaper than what I’d usually pay at the store, and a couple were actually a lot better than I expected, which was a nice suprrise.

Shipping was fine too, and nothing showed up broken or leaking. Not every wine was my absolute favorite, but for the money I realy can’t complain. It’s a good option if you just want decent wine around without spending a ton
RyanKennedy_97
March 22, 2026
"I reached out to support and, they..."
I reached out to support and, they replied way faster than I expected. Nice and easy.
James-pierce
March 19, 2026
"One of the bottles in my order..."
One of the bottles in my order showed up damaged, and I remember thinking, great, this is going to be a whole thing. i don’t even remember every detail of the back and forth because there wasn’t much to it. I emailed Wine Insiders, they replied quickly, and the refund was taken care of without me needing to keep following up. Simple and fair, which stuck with me. I’d order from them again.
joe-Scott
March 02, 2026
"Pleasantly surprised by how accurate it was"
I was a little surprised by how closely everything matched the description. What I got was pretty much exactly what was promised, which was nice to see.
margo1973
February 25, 2026
"Flexible wine club that’s been easy to stick with"
I’ve been using Wine Insiders for a bit now, and the flexibility is what I like most. I can skip a shipment or adjust things without feeling locked in (which is a big deal for me because I change my mind a lot).

The wines have been a little hit or miss, but I kind of expected that when trying bottles I wouldn’t normally pick on my own. Shipping has been totally fine so far, not lightning fast, but nothing I’d really complain about either (I’m not usually in a huge rush for wine).

Overall I’d say it’s a solid 4-star experience. It’s convenient, easy to manage, and a fun way to try new stuff, though I do wish the selections were a tiny bit more consistent sometimes.
Julie_payne86
February 17, 2026
"Good variety, but it took a while"
They’ve got a solid wine selection, definitely a lot of reds and whites I hadn’t seen before. I did spend longer than I expected browsing, and it took a while to figure out what I wanted. The options were good, but it was kind of a lot to sort through, and I kept feeling like it was taking forever. Still, I ended up finding a couple of good bottles, so not bad overall
debra_Tucker75
February 12, 2026
"Showed up sooner than I expected"
I thought it would take longer, but... my wine arrived in just a few days and everything was totally fine...
SaraMcclendon
February 05, 2026
"Pretty happy with Wine Insiders so far"
I’ve ordered from Wine Insiders a few times now, and it’s been a smooth experience. The website is easy enough to get around, and my boxes have arrived when they were supposed to. Everything was packed well too, so no broken bottles or anything like that.

The prices seem fair, and I like that I can try a bunch of different wines without overthinking it. I did have one small question for customer service, and they got back to me quickly. Has anyone else had a little delay getting a response, or was that just me? Overall though, I’m happy and would order again.
hello_julie453
February 04, 2026
"A Little Delivery Drama, But Dad Was Happy"
This gift order definitely had a bit of a dramatic entrance because it arrived late, which had me stressing for a minute. But in the end, my dad liked it, so the whole saga turned out okay.

View More Reviews

Wine Insiders Q&A

We were able to order any wines we chose for $6.49 a bottle. is there any possibility of buying more at this price?

Can i call my order in to wine insiders?

Can i call my order on the phone?

How long does shipping take

How do i get a replacement or refund for a very bad wine. i have 2 bottles of same.

angrybird413
April 21, 2020

“Hello, Carol, I apologize for that, what we can do is either provide you with a credit or a refund for those wines depending on the form of payment, there would be no need to return the bottles that you have. Please let me know what you would prefer to do. WIne Insiders”

View More Q&As

Have a question about Wine Insiders?

Customer Reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.